There's no such thing as bad publicity, right? If the old adage is true, the folks at Cold Brew Labs must be very, very happy at all of the 'free' publicity on the internets right now. Money couldn't buy the kind of coverage they're receiving.
As a concerned citizen of the www's, I've been picking up on the various conversations doing the rounds. I won't repost a lot of links here as what has been written is a lot more succinct and perhaps has more legal standing than I could present to you. But if you've been under a rock or if your eyes are starting to glaze over when you see the "P" word, then here's a quick summary as I see it.
Copyright and intellectual property rights are the main issues. Issues as old as the World Wide Web itself. Some photographers are not happy that their pictures are being pinned at all. Some craft sellers are not happy that their creations are being posted, with or without attribution, especially if there is a caption that reads something along the lines of "I am so going to make this!!" Some people are very worried about the Terms in regards to licensing and ownership of material on Pinterest. The terms 'fair use', 'visual collection', 'attribution', 'commercial purposes' as opposed to 'personal use' are cropping up in the discussions. People are 'tearfully deleting their boards' and leaving Pinterest. In response to some of those concerns, Pinterest has produced a line of code that can be added to websites to prevent Pinning from the site.
It's complex, fraught with controversy and ultimately, very much open to interpretation. But as usual, there is an element of sensationalism arising. Only a little searching and common sense tells me that some website owners are more than happy to have their posts, recipes and articles bookmarked publicly with the proper attribution. Some blog owners are very happy with the increase in hits that they can trace back to someone Pinning a picture from a post.
So here is my own personal Pinterest policy.
I will not be taking down my boards, tearfully or otherwise! I will be going over my pins with a fine-toothed comb. Each picture I've saved will be checked for it's back-link. If the original site has buttons that allow Pinning or posting on other social media sites, I will Pin them. If there is a specific Pinterest policy on the site, I will respect it. If the author of the site is a photographer, ie. photographs are their end product, I will probably not Pin, or I will contact the site owner and request permission.
I will only Re-Pin if the picture links back to an original site and it fits all of the criteria as above. There will be no more Pins from tumblr or Google image searches in my boards. (Applied retrospectively as I sift through my boards over the next few days).
I will not be making anymore 'Recently spotted on Pinterest' blog posts a) because you're probably already viewing them there, and b) they're an indication that I don't really have anything original to say so I should say nothing at all and c) they could be 'Pinned' by someone else and link back to me whereas they should link to their originator.
Out of respect to crafters and creatives, I will try to refrain from indicating an express wish to make the same item or similar. Having said that, I think this is an issue that predates the internet by centuries and it's perhaps being a wee bit precious to get up in arms about imitation that is done for personal use. Certainly, copying for commercial purposes is a no-no. But being inspired to use things I have on hand to create a similar item will not cause me to lose sleep. I've been in the craft business and I recognised long ago that fellow-creatives will often desire to recreate something they've seen that inspires them, rather than simply buy it. But realistically, (lack of) time and (lack of) ability to achieve a similar result will keep me buying Other People's creations and thereby keep the universe in balance.
As for my blogs, I will write a sharing policy for them but until then, images may be Pinned so long as they link directly back to the original blog post.
Lastly, I've re-read the Pinterest terms and satisfied myself that I can work relatively safely within them.
It is interesting to contemplate that within a very short space of time, the majority of website owners will have to contemplate where they stand on the issue of Pinterest. Not a bad start for the 'new kid' of social networking!